The 5th generation Legacy, sold from 2010 to 2014, was a major departure for Subaru. The car grew significantly larger to better compete in the American mid-size sedan market, and in the process, it ditched its signature frameless door glass. Powertrain options included a base 2.5L boxer-four, a powerful 3.6L boxer-six, and a turbocharged 2.5L boxer-four for the GT model.
The most desirable version by far is the Legacy 2.5GT, particularly with the 6-speed manual transmission. It's a genuine sleeper, sharing a detuned version of the contemporary WRX STI's engine, making it a quick and unassuming all-wheel-drive sedan. The 3.6R models are appreciated for their smooth power delivery and durability, making them excellent cruisers. Most other variants are valued simply as reliable, all-weather transportation.
Today's market reflects this split. The vast majority of 5th-gen Legacys are affordable daily drivers, with an average transaction price around $5,200. Clean, low-mileage 2.5GT manual examples are the exception, capable of fetching prices over $18,000. For most of the range, condition and maintenance history are more important than specific trim when determining value.
Buying Tips
- For 2.5GT models, prioritize a pre-purchase inspection that includes a compression test to check for EJ255 engine issues like head gaskets and ringlands.
- On cars with the Lineartronic CVT, confirm the service history. Early units require consistent fluid changes for long-term reliability.
- Inspect the front and rear subframes, rocker panels, and rear quarter panels for rust, especially on vehicles from northern climates.
- The 3.6R engine is known for its durability, but check for oil leaks from the timing chain cover and front seals.
- Look for a cracked dashboard, a common issue on these models, and test all interior electronics and power functions.
Prices range from $650 for project cars to $18,500 for well-preserved, low-mileage GT models.
250 Subaru Legacy 5th Gen vehicles have been tracked across auctions and listings on Hypercars, with 85 currently live.
Data sourced from Bring a Trailer, Cars & Bids, eBay Motors, PCarMarket, and Collecting Cars. Updated daily.
Run a business in this market?
Get Hypercars OS
