Subaru Legacy 5th Gen
The 5th generation Legacy grew in size but retained a potent turbocharged GT model, making it a true sleeper sedan. While most are affordable daily drivers, manual-equipped 2.5GTs remain sought-after by enthusiasts.
Find one with Spotter →Subaru Legacy 5th Gen sold for a median of $2,025 over the last 12 months, based on 11 auction sales; the middle 50% sold between $1,450 and $3,113. 85 currently for sale.
The 5th generation Legacy, sold from 2010 to 2014, was a major departure for Subaru. The car grew significantly larger to better compete in the American mid-size sedan market, and in the process, it ditched its signature frameless door glass. Powertrain options included a base 2.5L boxer-four, a powerful 3.6L boxer-six, and a turbocharged 2.5L boxer-four for the GT model.
The most desirable version by far is the Legacy 2.5GT, particularly with the 6-speed manual transmission. It's a genuine sleeper, sharing a detuned version of the contemporary WRX STI's engine, making it a quick and unassuming all-wheel-drive sedan. The 3.6R models are appreciated for their smooth power delivery and durability, making them excellent cruisers. Most other variants are valued simply as reliable, all-weather transportation.
Today's market reflects this split. The vast majority of 5th-gen Legacys are affordable daily drivers, with an average transaction price around $5,200. Clean, low-mileage 2.5GT manual examples are the exception, capable of fetching prices over $18,000. For most of the range, condition and maintenance history are more important than specific trim when determining value.
Buying Tips
- For 2.5GT models, prioritize a pre-purchase inspection that includes a compression test to check for EJ255 engine issues like head gaskets and ringlands.
- On cars with the Lineartronic CVT, confirm the service history. Early units require consistent fluid changes for long-term reliability.
- Inspect the front and rear subframes, rocker panels, and rear quarter panels for rust, especially on vehicles from northern climates.
- The 3.6R engine is known for its durability, but check for oil leaks from the timing chain cover and front seals.
- Look for a cracked dashboard, a common issue on these models, and test all interior electronics and power functions.
Prices range from $650 for project cars to $18,500 for well-preserved, low-mileage GT models.
250 Subaru Legacy 5th Gen vehicles have been tracked across auctions and listings on Hypercars, with 85 currently live.
Data sourced from Bring a Trailer, Cars & Bids, eBay Motors, PCarMarket, and Collecting Cars. Updated daily.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does a Subaru Legacy 5th Gen cost?
Over the last 12 months, Subaru Legacy 5th Gen sold for a median of $2,025 across 11 auction sales tracked on Hypercars; the middle 50% sold between $1,450 and $3,113. There are 85 currently for sale.
How many Subaru Legacy 5th Gen listings are for sale right now?
There are 85 Subaru Legacy 5th Gen listings currently live across auctions, dealers, and marketplaces tracked by Hypercars.